The most expensive town on this site, and the tightest inventory of any of them. Here is what the numbers actually say before you write an offer.
Start with the map. Filter by price, beds, and school district.
Start with the fact most people get wrong: Bargersville is more expensive than Fishers. The median single-family sale here is $460,000 year to date, against $440,000 in Fishers. If you came south expecting a discount, the numbers do not support it.
What you are paying for is a town that is still mostly new. Bargersville had about 9,570 people at the 2020 census and is now somewhere north of twelve thousand, which makes it the fastest-growing community in Johnson County. The town estimates roughly 800 platted home sites are sitting ready to be built on. Almost everything you will tour was built for someone who was moving in.
The four numbers in the box above look like they argue with each other. Prices up 9.5%. Volume down 23.6%. Days on market up from 30 to 45. And yet inventory fell to 1.6 months and sellers collected a larger share of list price than they did a year ago.
That is not a contradiction. It describes a supply problem, not a demand problem. Fewer homes sold because fewer homes were available to sell — not because buyers walked away. When inventory tightens and sellers still get 98% of list, that is a seller's market whatever the closing count says.
Forty-five days on market is the highest of any town on this site, and it sits oddly next to 1.6 months of supply. My read is that a good share of it is new construction: homes get listed while they are still being framed, and they accumulate days on market during a build they were always going to finish. That is a plausible explanation rather than a proven one — so when you are comparing two listings here, the first thing worth asking is whether you are looking at a finished resale or a house that has not been poured yet. The two are not the same forty-five days.
Where Bargersville works less well: if you want an established street with mature trees and a house older than you are, this is the wrong town. If you want a short commute to downtown Indianapolis, it is also the wrong town — you are roughly twenty miles south, and that is a real drive.
Every search below is live MLS data. Save one and you'll get new matches by email the morning they list.
There is no single Bargersville price. What an address is worth here turns on two things before anything else: which school corporation it falls in, and whether it is inside a subdivision or on county land.
The northern and western reaches, feeding Center Grove schools. This is where most of the demand and most of the premium sits, and it is the reason a lot of families look here at all.
See homes →East and south, in Franklin Community Schools. Often more house for the money than the Center Grove side, with a genuinely good district attached. Worth a look if your budget is tight.
See homes →The old town core, and the part that actually feels like a town. Taxman Brewing anchors it, and the town has been steadily adding to the street rather than around it.
See homes →Where most of those 800 ready home sites are. Incentives here are often better than a price cut, and they move quarter to quarter — ask before you assume the list price is the number.
See homes →Outside the subdivisions you get land, and with it septic, well, and a different appraisal conversation. Very different buying process. I'd want to walk one with you before you fall for it.
See homes →The east-west roads that determine your actual drive time, whichever subdivision you land in. Where you sit relative to these matters more than the map suggests.
See homes →This is the single most important thing to verify in Bargersville, and it catches people constantly. The town is served by two separate school corporations, and the boundary does not follow the town line.
Over 9,600 students across one high school, two middle schools and six elementaries, and one of the fastest-growing districts in the state. Center Grove High School is in Greenwood. Maple Grove and Walnut Grove elementaries sit in Bargersville.
About 5,100 students across one high school, two middle schools and five elementaries. Franklin Community High School is in Franklin. Union Elementary is in Bargersville.
Confirm the corporation by the specific address, not by the city on the listing and not by the subdivision name. Two houses on the same road can land in different districts. I check this on every showing, and I would rather tell you now than after you have fallen for a house.
You are roughly twenty miles south of downtown Indianapolis. Figure thirty to forty minutes depending on your route and the hour, with US 31 and State Road 135 doing most of the work. That range is wide for a reason — drive it once at your actual commute time before you commit.
Bargersville runs its own municipal electric utility. Your power bill comes from the town rather than from the investor-owned utility next door, and billing and service work differently than buyers coming from Indianapolis expect. Not a problem, just something to know before closing.
Indiana caps homestead property tax at 1% of gross assessed value under the circuit breaker, so most owner-occupants land at or near that figure. Rentals and second homes are not capped at 1% and should be modeled separately. Confirm specifics with the Johnson County Assessor.
Main Street has become a real destination rather than a pass-through, with Taxman Brewing as the anchor and a designated outdoor refreshment area downtown. The town has Umbarger Plaza in the works with a stage and green space for concerts. Beyond that you are close to Johnson County's park system and a short drive from everything in Greenwood.
The median single-family sale price was $460,000 year to date through August 2026, on 136 closings, up 9.5% from $419,998 over the same stretch of 2025. That is the highest median of any town I cover, and higher than Fishers.
Both Center Grove Community Schools and Franklin Community Schools serve parts of the town. Which one you are in depends on the specific address, not the city name or the subdivision. Always confirm by address before you write an offer.
Because supply tightened rather than demand falling away. Closings are down 23.6% year to date, but inventory also fell to 1.6 months and sellers collected 98.0% of list price, up from 96.5%. Fewer sales with less inventory and stronger pricing is a shortage, not a slowdown.
My read is that new construction is doing a lot of the work in that number — houses listed before they are finished carry days on market while they are being built. When you compare two listings, check whether you are looking at a finished resale or a house that has not broken ground.
No. The year-to-date median is $460,000 in Bargersville against $440,000 in Fishers. Bargersville also had tighter inventory in August, at 1.6 months, the same as Fishers. If price is the driver, Fortville and McCordsville are the better places to look.
Roughly thirty to forty minutes depending on route and time of day, via US 31 or State Road 135. It is about twenty miles. If you have a hard start time downtown, drive it once before you buy.
Yes, more than anywhere else on this site. The town estimates around 800 platted home sites are ready to build on. Builder incentives here are often worth more than an equivalent price cut, and they change quarter to quarter, so it is worth asking rather than assuming.
I'm Wes Johnston, a Realtor with Trueblood Real Estate. I work across the Indianapolis metro, and Bargersville is one of the markets where the gap between what people assume and what the data says is widest.
My job isn't to open doors. It's to tell you what a house is actually worth, what's wrong with it, and whether it's the right move for what you're trying to do — then negotiate hard on your behalf and own the process from contract to close.
If you're two years out, that's fine. Most of my best clients started with a question, not a showing.
Indianapolis metro specialist. Committed to your success.
Set up a saved search and you'll get new Bargersville listings the day they come on the market — usually a few days ahead of the national sites. No spam, and you can turn it off any time.
Start My Bargersville SearchNot a national algorithm guessing from square footage. A real valuation based on what's actually selling near you, from someone who has been inside those houses.